Orchestras Hire Youthful Conductors to Stay Relevant. Is that Enough?

What can symphony orchestras learn from “Mozart in the Jungle,” the Amazon series featuring a dashing young conductor from Mexico who replaces the aging music director of an orchestra, in a bid to invigorate the stodgy institution? In this Slate article from Feb. 4, 2016, I look at various factors that contribute to an orchestra’s perceived relevance and value in its community – starting with the conductors who stand on the podium.

“Orchestras across the country have been buffeted by deficits, declining attendance, and labor unrest; and the Philharmonic, while in better health than many, remains a medium-sized fish in a New York cultural pond dominated by Broadway, fashion, and the latest restaurant openings. While a conductor’s first responsibility is to the music, is it possible in 2016 for the face of an arts institution—or one that wants to remain relevant, anyway—to avoid engaging with the social and cultural context in which he makes his art?” Read on.

Photo: Gael García Bernal as Rodrigo in ‘Mozart in the Jungle’ (Amazon)

Seattle Symphony Stages Concert to Celebrate Immigrants

The Seattle Symphony staged a kind of protest concert on Wednesday night, featuring composers and performers from the seven Muslim majority countries that Donald Trump has sought to bar from entering the United States. Continue reading “Seattle Symphony Stages Concert to Celebrate Immigrants”

Eight Takeaways from Classical Music in 2016

In a year in which the 2016 presidential campaign impacted all corners of public life in the U.S., classical music often served as a diversion or even a refuge for many listeners. But musicians didn’t live in a vacuum either, as several news stories demonstrated. Continue reading “Eight Takeaways from Classical Music in 2016”

Three Orchestra Strikes: Considering Artistic Health

As the fall 2016 concert season begins, the musicians of three big-city orchestras are on strike: the Philadelphia Orchestra, Pittsburgh Symphony and Fort Worth Symphony. Continue reading “Three Orchestra Strikes: Considering Artistic Health”

5 Takeaways from Classical Music Virtual Reality Projects

The classical music field has had an on-and-off relationship with online gaming and personal technology. Back in 2007, users of the Nintendo Wii could play a new virtual reality-type game called the Virtual Maestro, which turned the Wii controller (which resembled a TV remote) into a baton to manipulate a digital orchestra’s tempo. Before that, there was the Concert Companion, a pre-smartphone era device that was intended to provide realtime program notes at concerts. Continue reading “5 Takeaways from Classical Music Virtual Reality Projects”

New Jersey Arts Groups Grapple With Changing Audiences

Working in the shadow of a major city is a challenge faced by suburban arts organizations across the United States, but especially in New Jersey, where New York City and Philadelphia act as strong magnets for culture lovers. The state’s opera companies have particularly struggled to stay afloat, not only in recent times, but for well over a decade. Continue reading “New Jersey Arts Groups Grapple With Changing Audiences”

New Orchestras Focus on the ‘Now’ and ‘Nu’

“The musicians you see here are not from central casting—they’re conservatory-trained,” Bard College president and conductor Leon Botstein assured audiences on Friday night as he introduced The Orchestra Now, Bard’s new graduate training ensemble. Continue reading “New Orchestras Focus on the ‘Now’ and ‘Nu’”

The Year 2015 in Classical Music Videos

For the final week of 2015, the pop music critics of the New York Times put together a survey of their top music videos of the year. A couple of the choices crossed into classical territory, including an intriguing video for Terry Riley’s minimalist landmark In C. Continue reading “The Year 2015 in Classical Music Videos”

Podium Powers: Hispanic Conductors on the Rise

Jacomo Rafael Bairos leads his first concert as music director of the Amarillo Symphony on July 4, 2013.
Jacomo Rafael Bairos leads his first concert as music director of the Amarillo Symphony Orchestra on July 4, 2013.

This article originally appeared in Symphony, the magazine of the League of American Orchestras.

When José-Luis Novo was asked to conduct Latin American music early in his career, he frequently declined, fearing people would peg him as a Hispanic specialist. Novo, who left his native Spain to study at Yale University as a Fulbright Scholar, would sometimes conduct Spanish-flavored works by Ravel or Falla, but also made sure to include plenty of Berlioz or Tchaikovsky on his programs.

But increasingly, Novo is happy for the chance to conduct repertoire f rom his home country and by other Latino composers. He opened a recent season at the Annapolis Symphony Orchestra, where he has been music director since 2007, with music by Revueltas, Ginastera, Piazzolla, and Gabriela Lena Frank. In May he will conduct Diez Melodías Vascas (Ten Basque Melodies) by the Spanish composer Jesús Guridi. “Now at this point in my career I’m eager to do more of it,” says Novo of Spanish-themed programming. “I like to think I have a special affinity that other conductors don’t have. It makes a special connection with the musicians. You have access to information that others don’t.”

Novo’s experience attests to the underlying tensions that Latino conductors face as they assume a sometimes uneasy variety of roles: as de facto standard-bearers for their native traditions—highlighted in community-engagement events—and as artists who grasp the core canon of Bach through Stravinsky. When, in the 1930s, the Mexican composer and conductor Carlos Chavez toured the U.S. and led nearly all of the top American orchestras, attitudes were starkly different. Despite advocacy from an establishment figure like Aaron Copland, Chavez was seen as somewhat of an exotic specimen, with one music critic expressing amazement at “his genuine grounding in the classic tradition.”

But in the last five years or so, roughly a dozen American music directorships have gone to Hispanics, including those at the Los Angeles Philharmonic (Venezuelan Gustavo Dudamel), Houston Symphony (Colombian Andrés Orozco-Estrada), Nashville Symphony (Giancarlo Guerrero, from Costa Rica), and Orchestra of St. Luke’s (Pablo Heras-Casado, from Spain), along with several smaller-budget ensembles. Assistant and resident directorships have seen similar trends, reflecting a growing pipeline of talent. Latinas are underrepresented but not altogether absent, with women like Gisele Ben-Dor (born in Uruguay), Joana Carneiro (the Portuguese-born music director at California’s Berkeley Symphony), and Alondra de la Parra (who led the New York-based Orchestra of the Americas from 2004 until its collapse amid labor troubles in 2011, and is now active in Mexico).

Aaron Dworkin, founder of the nonprofit Sphinx Organization, which encourages and supports the participation of blacks and Latinos in classical music, believes that the Los Angeles Philharmonic’s hiring of Dudamel in 2008 largely triggered the current trend involving conductors. “Once the field saw how tremendously successful that was, to have someone young and representing a community not often represented on the podium, sometimes it takes that for us to get it,” he says. Dworkin cautions that conductors, while important, are just one piece of a larger matrix. “Seeing more Latinos on the podium is a fantastic thing in and of itself—a transformation for an institution,” he continues. “But it will never be enough. All of those orchestras need to see how can we have this impact on our audience, our repertoire, our membership on stage, even our staff and our board.”

Indeed, as with American orchestra musicians, Hispanic conductors active in the U.S. still lag far behind their demographic representation in the country as a whole; the 2010 U.S. Census showed that Hispanics account for 16.7 percent of the U.S. population but, according to a 2010 report by the League of American Orchestras, only 2.3 percent of orchestra musicians are Hispanic.

Still, some observers are encouraged by the outcomes of vast public music education initiatives like El Sistema in Venezuela and Batuta in Colombia. What’s more, this vibrant mix of nationalities is also the largest-growing segment of the classical music audience according to another study by the League, the 2009 Audience Demographic Research Review, and there is a growing awareness that this audience must be better served. The census underscored this, showing that racial and ethnic minorities accounted for 90 percent of the population growth over the past decade, and that Hispanics are by far the largest part of that increase. Moreover, as Hispanics’ buying power increases, they are going to be voracious consumers of entertainment and media–more so than white audiences, according to a 2013 Nielsen Research study.

When the Amarillo Symphony in Texas hired Jacomo Rafael Bairos last July as its music director, the organization was candid about its desire to reach Amarillo’s growing Hispanic community. “Part of the process there was getting to know the needs of the town,” says Bairos, who was born in Portugal, raised mostly in Miami, and speaks Spanish and Portuguese. The population of Amarillo is 29 percent Hispanic. “Having that as part of my culture growing up definitely influenced my musical tastes and style. I’m excited now I get to share that in Amarillo.”

Bairos says discussions about reaching Hispanic audiences have mostly centered on programming: including more Latin-American pieces throughout the season, and possibly presenting a festival in spring 2015 centered on music from the Americas. “If we start to infuse programs with a sort of Latin tinge, we can hopefully start to reach out to different demographics,” he notes.

Six months before Bairos’s appointment, another Texas orchestra, the Houston Symphony, announced that Colombian-born Andrés Orozco-Estrada would be its next music director. In an online promotional video, the orchestra’s managers tout the fact that Orozco-Estrada “possesses personality and a Hispanic background” and they note that he is fluent in Spanish, German, and English. The city’s mayor, Annise Parker, makes an appearance in the video, noting that the conductor has a “diverse story to fit into the local community.”

Thanks to a large influx of immigrants over the past several decades, Houston has become what is sometimes termed a “majority minority” city, with 60 percent of its residents of African, Hispanic, or Asian descent. Hispanics constitute a 44 percent share, according to the 2010 Census, up from 37 percent in 2000. Orozco-Estrada follows Hans Graf, a 64-year-old Austrian who has led the ensemble for twelve years.

Orozco-Estrada declined to be interviewed for this article, citing schedule conflicts. But there remains a reticence among Hispanic conductors to draw attention to their ethnicity, and in interviews, some dismissed suggestions that Spanish- or Latin-themed programs can serve as a community-engagement strategy. If anything, most conductors try to blend works by Hispanic composers with Latin-themed pieces from the European canon; a piece by Ginastera, Villa-Lobos, or Golijov will often sit beside Ravel’s Rapsodie espagnole, Copland’s El Salón México, or Bizet’s Carmen.

Miguel Harth-Bedoya, music director of the Fort Worth Symphony, speaks to the audience at an open house event (Credit: Richard Rodriguez)
Miguel Harth-Bedoya, music director of the Fort Worth Symphony, speaks to the audience at an open house event (Credit: Richard Rodriguez)

“Music is music,” says Miguel Harth-Bedoya, the Peruvian-born music director of the Fort Worth Symphony Orchestra since 2000. “Only certain politicians have used music at certain times for a purpose. I want to stay away from that. If anything, our Hispanic community has become more attached to what we have become as an institution than to coming to hear music from Latin America.”

Harth-Bedoya has been working steadily to bring more Hispanic music into the repertory through his multimedia project, Caminos del Inka, which he started in 2007 and has brought to a number of U.S. orchestras. The multimedia project was in- spired by the Inca Trail, a series of ancient pathways that link Peru, Bolivia, Ecuador, Colombia, Chile, and Argentina, as it explores and highlights the classical music of South America. But Harth-Bedoya says it’s not about targeting audiences, and that he has taken it to cities like Oslo, Norway and Helsinki, Finland—neither of which has a large Hispanic population—and received an enthusiastic response.

Jesse Rosen, president and CEO of the League of American Orchestras, believes current trends are
part of the natural ebb and flow. He disputes the idea that orchestras select conductors specifically to connect with Hispanic communities. “I don’t think orchestras are seeking that out particularly,” he says. “There’s definitely a heightened awareness of the potential for growing an audience among Spanish-speaking people, but it’s hard to imagine that would be a driving force in hiring a music director.

“Still, in every instance,” Rosen adds, “what’s most important is the chemistry that happens with an orchestra and the kind of music-making that happens. Having said that, I’m sure in some communities it’s a huge plus to have a conductor of Hispanic descent.” Much of the activity by orchestras to connect with Spanish-speaking communities, Rosen notes, is driven not by the music director but by other departments in the organization, such as education and marketing.

Recent audience trends suggest that more targeted engagement with Hispanics will be necessary to turn them into repeat concertgoers. The 2009 Audience Demographic Research Review by the League—which combined data from the NEA and the Experian Simmons National Hispanic Consumer Study—found that participation rates among classical music audiences declined 9.3 percent between 2003 and 2007. Among Hispanics, the drop was not quite as steep, at 8.1 percent. But more telling was the study’s ten-year forecast: Hispanics’ share of the classical audience is expected to grow from about 12 percent in 2008 to 20 percent in 2018. This is driven chiefly by population increases, but also to some degree by a growth in interest and spending power among Hispanics.

Nevertheless, significant challenges lie ahead. The League’s 2009 report acknowledges that “marketers are struggling to convert Hispanics to repeat attendance,” whether through Spanish-language media, grassroots awareness building, or festivals around cultural themes (Cinco de Mayo, Día de los Muertos). The report was also published well before the recent spate of conductor appointments and new Census data.

Knowing Your Community

The Chicago Symphony Orchestra set out two years ago with a plan to build its Latino audience. While the orchestra had long produced a patchwork of events for the city’s Mexican population, now it enlisted the Purple Group, a communications firm focused on the Hispanic community, to conduct market research.

“Knowing that our community’s Latino population is growing, our marketing has to change with it,” says Liz Madeja, the orchestra’s director of marketing. In January 2013, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra formed the CSO Latino Alliance, a networking group that aims to spread the word about the orchestra through professional connections. The orchestra hosts quarterly pre- and post-concert events for the group, whose eighteen members invite their colleagues from the Hispanic business community. The CSO is building a database and has established goals of a 10- to 20-percent annual growth in Hispanic audiences, with a particular focus on 30- to 50-year-olds. Madeja says that the CSO Latino Alliance events have centered on Latino program- ming—reflected in the conductor, soloist, or program—though the orchestra is find- ing that members are also happy to come hear Tchaikovsky’s Romeo and Juliet.

Indeed, conservative musical tastes are not to be underestimated, regardless of ethnicity. A May 2013 CSO concert of music by Revueltas and Ginastera was marked by empty seats, according to a Chicago Tribune review. The conductor, Carlos Miguel Prieto, recently led a similar program with the Houston Symphony. (The orchestra did not respond to requests for comment on the program, though a review in the Houston Press suggested a more successful audience response on the opening night.) “Doing diverse repertoire doesn’t mean playing for a certain community,” says Prieto, music director of the Louisiana Philharmonic since 2005 and since 2011 of the YOA Orchestra of the Americas. “In other words, I don’t think the Houston Sym- phony is doing this—or should be doing this—because of the fact that Houston has such a big Latin community. I think it’s just worthy, period.”

Orchestras are also wary of seeming to pigeonhole an audience they may not fully understand. Institutions like the CSO have found that improved, ongoing dialogue with a community is more crucial than top-down, one-time engagement events. Current thinking is that concertgoing habits, no matter where one is f rom, don’t come naturally. But orchestras can count on the aspirational factor: people of all colors and classes want their children to have exposure to music, and that may be a real key to bringing Latinos to the symphony.

Ultimately, one-off concerts aimed at a specific ethnic community may have little impact. The Annapolis Symphony reports that it has seen little if any uptick in Hispanic patrons since Novo assumed the directorship. But Novo believes the current influx of Latino conductors itself is encouraging. “Being a Latin American or Hispanic, now there are role models,” he said. “Now you can tell there is a lot of Hispanic talent in the conducting world, and people can tell you it’s there. The fact that Hispanic conductors and composers are pretty much accepted because we have some very good examples makes it easy for us, because we don’t have to fight as much.”

More than ever, as classical music works to entice new listeners, it will be essential for a music director to be a cultural leader in the community, a proselytizer-in-chief for the art form. Just as Yo-Yo Ma became a figurehead for Asian classical musicians a generation ago, and singers like Leontyne Price and Jessye Norman carried the flag for African-Americans in opera, Hispanic conductors may have a similar ability to reach kids from Paraguay to Portugal: they may see someone on the podium who looks like them, who speaks their language, who comes from their same country, and be inspired.

New York Thrill

Alan Gilbert conducts the New York Philharmonic at Avery Fisher Hall, 10/23/14. (credit: Chris Lee)
Alan Gilbert conducts the New York Philharmonic at Avery Fisher Hall, 10/23/14. (credit: Chris Lee)

This article appeared in the September 2012 issue of the BBC Music Magazine.

An ambitious project to resurrect the works of Danish composer Carl Nielsen is just one of the many innovations of the New York Philharmonic’s music director Alan Gilbert. Brian Wise meets New York’s musical visionary.

With all the ways that the New York Philharmonic has seized the news headlines in 2012 – a mobile phone halting a performance of Mahler, players quitting or retiring, a massive concert in the hangar-like Park Avenue Armory – you might think that a recording cycle of Carl Nielsen’s music for a small Danish label would be fairly low among the orchestra’s priorities.

The Danish composer’s six symphonies and three concertos are often viewed as post-Romantic curiosities, tagged with odd nicknames (‘The Inextinguishable’) and overshadowed by fellow Nordic composer Jean Sibelius. For a famously brash orchestra known for its Beethoven, Mahler and Tchaikovsky, this corner of the repertoire may seem too arcane to merit significant advocacy. But Alan Gilbert, who is entering his fourth season as the Philharmonic’s first New York-born music director, believes he can raise Nielsen’s visibility where his predecessors could not. ‘Leonard Bernstein was most famously excited by the music of Nielsen,’ says Gilbert during an interview in the same modest Lincoln Center office once used by Bernstein. ‘But it doesn’t seem to have quite taken hold. I’m not sure why because it’s eminently approachable and understandable music.’

The Philharmonic is one of a handful of orchestras recording Nielsen’s symphonies and concertos (for violin, flute and clarinet) in the lead-up to the 150th anniversary of the composer’s birth in 2015. This represents the first big push since the Nielsen revival of the 1960s, marked by Bernstein’s recording of the Third and Fifth Symphonies. But that boom never quite took hold, however, aside from a smattering of releases by Eugene Ormandy, Jascha Horenstein and Herbert Blomstedt.

Gilbert believes audiences will follow his passion, even as it shares a crowded agenda at the Philharmonic. ‘Even on the first hearing it’s obviously right out of the central European symphonic tradition,’ Gilbert says of the symphonies. ‘What I like about it is it takes that tradition and makes something very unique. I don’t know if it’s Danish or if it’s just Nielsen himself but there’s kind of a quirky persona that speaks through this essentially traditional symphonic form.’

The first release in ‘The Nielsen Project’ is due out in October on the Dacapo label and will feature live concert recordings of the Second and Third Symphonies. The Third, recorded in June at Avery Fisher Hall, showed why Nielsen’s music can be so strange but also compelling: it opens with big unison chords set out in increasingly asymmetrical rhythms which stumble into a kind of drunken waltz. Later, a baritone and a soprano deliver a vocalise while standing in the midst of the orchestra. Nielsen himself played in the second violin section during the premiere of his First Symphony, in 1894. ‘Nielsen was an extremely well- schooled musician and fascinating person from what I understand,’ says Gilbert. ‘He was apparently well known for doing impressions and dressing up as different characters. There are actually some photographs of him in various poses and various outfits – including dresses. That kind of desire to express different personalities and characters comes through in his music.’

The 45-year-old Gilbert has been on a Nielsen campaign since serving as chief conductor of the Royal Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra, from 2000 to 2008. His Nordic orientation quickly carried over in New York. He named the Finn Magnus Lindberg as composer in residence and opened his inaugural concert in 2009 with the composer’s piece EXPO. Recently he led a new song cycle by the Swedish composer Anders Hillborg, with Renée Fleming as soloist.

Gilbert has also shown more sympathy towards European modernists than US composers, although this season marks a change with the arrival of Christopher Rouse as the next composer in residence. Now starting the fourth year in a five-year contract, Gilbert leads a 170-year-old institution that faces many of the same uncertainties that confront other US orchestras. Musicians have a new two-year contract, but hefty pension liabilities remain. A renovation of the widely scorned Avery Fisher Hall is planned in the near future, which will displace the ensemble for a long period. And Matthew VanBesien, the orchestra’s new executive director, hired from the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra, is unknown in New York.

The New York Philharmonic and Alan Gilbert (photo: Chris Lee)
The New York Philharmonic and Alan Gilbert (photo: Chris Lee)

The Philharmonic gets generally high marks for its sound and character, but critics have prodded Gilbert to follow his more adventurous instincts – even as he has moved the programming beyond the staidness of his predecessor Lorin Maazel. Close observers say that the Philharmonic remains a conservative institution in many respects and Gilbert must balance his more daring nature with the tastes of an old-school subscriber base.

Even so, Gilbert has whipped up a bit of visual spectacle for the Philharmonic’s season-closers since arriving, with staged operas – Ligeti’s Le Grande Macabre in 2010, and Janácek’s The Cunning Little Vixen in 2011 – that brought clever, colourful costumes and sets into Avery Fisher Hall. This year, the spectacle was the most audacious yet: an evening of surround-sound works that included a scene from Mozart’s Don Giovanni, pieces by Boulez and Ives, and one of the summits of the avant-garde, Stockhausen’s Gruppen. The event took place in the 55,000-square-foot Drill Hall of the Park Avenue Armory in Manhattan.

‘It was an experiment and one that generally went well,’ says Gilbert. He was especially satisfied with having pulled off Gruppen – a 1957 work that calls for three orchestras, each with its own conductor, arrayed in a horseshoe around the audience. Gilbert acknowledged that the Act I finale from Don Giovanni – in which the cast sang from all corners – wasn’t entirely successful given the Armory’s large acoustics. ‘We’ve learned a lot and that was another reason why we wanted to do it because I think we have some exciting vocal projects planned for the future in the Armory and now we’ll know much better how to deal with those.’

But besides being a logistical feat, the project had true event status in a city where a daily commute can be an event. The two performances were sold out weeks in advance and they drew a younger audience. ‘What I hoped would happen is happening – that there is kind of an identity and trust with the audience that is getting stronger,’ says Gilbert. ‘That’s simply because we do something people are going to be interested in taking part in, trying it out and taking the risk.’

The Philharmonic says it is undertaking audience research to understand who attends these big season-ending concerts, and what else they might be attracted to. That might include next June’s Stravinsky’s Petrushka, featuring puppets, dancers, live animation and video, in a production created by Doug Fitch.

These events represent a vastly different image of the Philharmonic experience than one that made global headlines earlier this year, when a subscriber’s mobile phone went off during the delicate final pages of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony. In the heat of the moment, Gilbert made a nearly unprecedented move: he stopped the performance. The ringing kept on going, however, and audiences were soon baying for blood. ‘Kick him out,’ they screamed, ‘Go home!’. Gilbert turned around and said, matter-of-factly, ‘We’ll wait.’ Days of blanket news media coverage followed.

‘I was surprised and not a little fascinated that it struck such a chord,’ says Gilbert, now admitting he enjoyed the story. ‘It’s actually an encouraging sign that people find it so blasphemous, almost, to interrupt a concert. It’s like something went against nature. I think it’s actually a good sign for what we do and how people view what we do.’